Breathing New Life into a Midcentury Fireplace
This discovery was followed by a quote for more than $3,000 to repair it! Double-yuck. Time to explore some options.
The first suggestion was gas logs. The idea of fake wood didn’t really thrill us. We decided to go with a more modern-style burner called Loft by Empire Comfort Systems. I opted for the basic 36″ version and purchased it locally from Jack Wills Outdoor. These can be spruced up with remote control, stainless steel cover and fire glass, beads, or even stone. They are available in various sizes with heat outputs ranging from 8000 to 40,000 BTUs.
Fireplace inserts like this are available in vented and non-vented styles. The cost and installation involved vary widely between the two. Vented models are essentially self-contained boxes that require venting to the outdoors and a supply of fresh air. Non-vented (also called ventless, vent-free or unvented) install more like a set of gas logs that just sit inside your fireplace. There are advantages and drawbacks to both.
We were interested in the “look” of a fire, but also wanted to gain some warmth benefit. I learned the non-vented burners run so clean there is no need to open the damper. So the warmth stays in the room instead of rushing up the flue. Plus the installation is a breeze compared to the enclosure and vent pipes required for a vented unit.
After installation I set up a CO/gas monitor to make sure there was no excessive emissions fouling the living room. Everything seemed fine until I detected a slight whiff of natural gas near the main valve in the fireplace. Ruh-roh!
Turns out this quite common. These valves are installed to speed up the process of lighting the fireplace. In common use, you typically open the valve for a few minutes and turn it off once the fire is lit. If the valve is leaking you don’t really notice in this scenario.
With a fireplace insert or gas logs the gas valve remains open, either all the time or during use. I tried the simple repair of tightening the gland nut, which will often seal the packing enough to cure a leak. No luck.
As you can see, replacing the valve would have been a major headache. Eventually I tried an old trick from my automotive days: Hylomar. This gasket sealer from the UK was used to seal threads on the carburetors of British sports cars. No mean feat! The blue goo remains pliable and is impervious to gasoline… so I assumed it wouldn’t mind exposure to a little methane.
The Hylomar trick worked, and is still working almost a year later!
Here’s the finished product. We decided not to add the stainless steel panel or glass rock or anything else. The look of the fire “floating” in the space is a look we like so the basic unit pretty much satisfied our need.
Once lit the heat can be felt in the room almost immediately.
The unit has a pilot so turning on/off is merely a flip of a switch. Optional remotes and thermostats are also available for the gadget hungry. But so far we haven’t found it that burdensome to walk over and flip the switch.
Shop for a Loft Vent-Free Burner on Amazon.